All-AFC Teams: 1990s | 2010s | 2020s
2000 |
| Offense | | | Defense | | | Special Teams | |
QB | Rich Gannon | OAK | DE | Trace Armstrong | MIA | PK | Matt Stover | BAL |
RB | Eddie George | TEN | DE | Jason Taylor | MIA | P | Darren Bennett | SD |
RB | Edgerrin James | IND | DT | Sam Adams | BAL | KR | Derrick Mason | TEN |
WR | Marvin Harrison | IND | DT | Trevor Pryce | DEN | PR | Derrick Mason | TEN |
WR | Rod Smith | DEN | OLB | Mo Lewis | NYJ | ST | Larry Izzo | MIA |
TE | Tony Gonzalez | KC | OLB | Junior Seau | SD | | | |
C | Tom Nalen | DEN | MLB | Ray Lewis | BAL | | | |
G | Alan Faneca | PIT | CB | Sam Madison | MIA | | | |
G | Steve Wisniewski | OAK | CB | Samari Rolle | TEN | | | |
T | Brad Hopkins | TEN | S | Brock Marion | MIA | | | |
T | Jonathan Ogden | BAL | S | Rod Woodson | BAL | | | |
2001 |
| Offense | | | Defense | | | Special Teams | |
QB | Rich Gannon | OAK | DE | John Abraham | NYJ | PK | Jason Elam | DEN |
RB | Priest Holmes | KC | DE | Marcellus Wiley | SD | P | Shane Lechler | OAK |
RB | Curtis Martin | NYJ | DT | Sam Adams | BAL | KR | Jermaine Lewis | BAL |
WR | Marvin Harrison | IND | DT | John Randle | SEA | PR | Troy Brown | NE |
WR | Rod Smith | DEN | OLB | Jason Gildon | PIT | ST | Ian Gold | DEN |
TE | Tony Gonzalez | KC | OLB | Jamir Miller | CLE | | | |
C | Kevin Mawae | NYJ | MLB | Ray Lewis | BAL | | | |
G | Alan Faneca | PIT | CB | Deltha O'Neal | DEN | | | |
G | Will Shields | KC | CB | Sam Madison
Charles Woodson | MIA
OAK | | | |
T | Lincoln Kennedy | OAK | S | Rodney Harrison | SD | | | |
T | Jonathan Ogden | BAL | S | Lawyer Milloy | NE | | | |
2002 |
| Offense | | | Defense | | | Special Teams | |
QB | Rich Gannon | OAK | DE | John Abraham | NYJ | PK | Adam Vinatieri | NE |
RB | Priest Holmes | KC | DE | Jason Taylor | MIA | P | Chris Hanson | JAX |
RB | Ricky Williams | MIA | DT | Richard Seymour | NE | KR | Chad Morton | NYJ |
WR | Marvin Harrison | IND | DT | Gary Walker | HOU | PR | Santana Moss | NYJ |
WR | Hines Ward | PIT | OLB | Keith Bulluck | TEN | ST | Larry Izzo | NO |
TE | Tony Gonzalez | KC | OLB | Joey Porter | PIT | | | |
C | Kevin Mawae | NYJ | MLB | Zach Thomas | MIA | | | |
G | Alan Faneca | PIT | CB | Aaron Glenn | HOU | | | |
G | Will Shields | KC | CB | Patrick Surtain | MIA | | | |
T | Lincoln Kennedy | OAK | S | Lance Schulters | HOU | | | |
T | Jonathan Ogden | BAL | S | Rod Woodson | OAK | | | |
2003 |
| Offense | | | Defense | | | Special Teams | |
QB | Peyton Manning | IND | DE | Dwight Freeney | IND | PK | Mike Vanderjagt | IND |
RB | Priest Holmes | KC | DE | Adewale Ogunleye | MIA | P | Craig Hentrich | TEN |
RB | Jamal Lewis | BAL | DT | Richard Seymour | NE | KR | Dante Hall | KC |
WR | Marvin Harrison | IND | DT | Marcus Stroud | JAX | PR | Dante Hall | KC |
WR | Chad Johnson | CIN | OLB | Keith Bulluck | TEN | ST | Adalius Thomas | BAL |
TE | Tony Gonzalez | KC | OLB | Takeo Spikes | BUF | | | |
C | Tom Nalen | DEN | MLB | Ray Lewis | BAL | | | |
G | Alan Faneca | PIT | CB | Ty Law | NE | | | |
G | Will Shields | KC | CB | Patrick Surtain | MIA | | | |
T | Jonathan Ogden | BAL | S | Rodney Harrison | NE | | | |
T | Willie Roaf | KC | S | Ed Reed | BAL | | | |
2004 |
| Offense | | | Defense | | | Special Teams | |
QB | Peyton Manning | IND | DE | Dwight Freeney | IND | PK | Adam Vinatieri | NE |
RB | Edgerrin James | IND | DE | Jason Taylor | MIA | P | Shane Lechler | OAK |
RB | Curtis Martin | NYJ | DT | Richard Seymour | NE | KR | Terrence McGee | BUF |
WR | Marvin Harrison | IND | DT | Marcus Stroud | JAX | PR | B.J. Sams | BAL |
WR | Chad Johnson | CIN | OLB | Joey Porter | PIT | ST | Larry Izzo | NE |
TE | Antonio Gates | SD | OLB | Takeo Spikes | BUF | | | |
C | Kevin Mawae | NYJ | MLB | James Farrior | PIT | | | |
G | Alan Faneca | PIT | CB | Champ Bailey | DEN | | | |
G | Will Shields | KC | CB | Chris McAlister | BAL | | | |
T | Jonathan Ogden | BAL | S | Troy Polamalu | PIT | | | |
T | Willie Roaf | KC | S | Ed Reed | BAL | | | |
2005 |
| Offense | | | Defense | | | Special Teams | |
QB | Peyton Manning | IND | DE | Derrick Burgess | OAK | PK | Shayne Graham | CIN |
RB | Edgerrin James | IND | DE | Dwight Freeney | IND | P | Brian Moorman | BUF |
RB | Larry Johnson | KC | DT | Richard Seymour | NE | KR | Jerome Mathis | HOU |
WR | Marvin Harrison | IND | DT | Jamal Williams | SD | PR | Antwaan Randle El | PIT |
WR | Chad Johnson | CIN | OLB | Cato June | IND | ST | Hanik Milligan | SD |
TE | Antonio Gates | SD | OLB | Joey Porter | PIT | | | |
C | Jeff Saturday | IND | MLB | Al Wilson | DEN | | | |
G | Alan Faneca | PIT | CB | Champ Bailey | DEN | | | |
G | Will Shields | KC | CB | Deltha O'Neal | CIN | | | |
T | Willie Anderson | CIN | S | Troy Polamalu | PIT | | | |
T | Willie Roaf | KC | S | Bob Sanders | IND | | | |
2006 |
| Offense | | | Defense | | | Special Teams | |
QB | Peyton Manning | IND | DE | Aaron Schobel | BUF | PK | Nate Kaeding | SD |
RB | Larry Johnson | KC | DE | Jason Taylor | MIA | P | Brian Moorman | BUF |
RB | LaDainian Tomlinson | SD | DT | Richard Seymour | NE | KR | Justin Miller | NYJ |
WR | Marvin Harrison | IND | DT | Jamal Williams | SD | PR | Adam Jones | TEN |
WR | Chad Johnson | CIN | OLB | Shawne Merriman | SD | ST | Kassim Osgood | SD |
TE | Antonio Gates | SD | OLB | Adalius Thomas | BAL | | | |
C | Jeff Saturday | IND | MLB | Zach Thomas | MIA | | | |
G | Alan Faneca | PIT | CB | Champ Bailey | DEN | | | |
G | Will Shields | KC | CB | Rashean Mathis | JAX | | | |
T | Willie Anderson | CIN | S | Ed Reed | BAL | | | |
T | Jonathan Ogden | BAL | S | Kerry Rhodes | NYJ | | | |
2007 |
| Offense | | | Defense | | | Special Teams | |
QB | Tom Brady | NE | DE | Jared Allen | KC | PK | Rob Bironas | TEN |
RB | Willie Parker | PIT | DE | Kyle Vanden Bosch | TEN | P | Shane Lechler | OAK |
RB | LaDainian Tomlinson | SD | DT | Albert Haynesworth | TEN | KR | Josh Cribbs | CLE |
WR | Randy Moss | NE | DT | Vince Wilfork | NE | PR | Roscoe Parrish | BUF |
WR | Reggie Wayne | IND | OLB | James Harrison | PIT | ST | Kassim Osgood | SD |
TE | Antonio Gates | SD | OLB | Mike Vrabel | NE | | | |
C | Jeff Saturday | IND | MLB | DeMeco Ryans | HOU | | | |
G | Alan Faneca | PIT | CB | Antonio Cromartie | SD | | | |
G | Logan Mankins | NE | CB | Asante Samuel | NE | | | |
T | Matt Light | NE | S | Ed Reed | BAL | | | |
T | Jason Peters | BUF | S | Bob Sanders | IND | | | |
2008 |
| Offense | | | Defense | | | Special Teams | |
QB | Peyton Manning | IND | DE | Robert Mathis | IND | PK | Stephen Gostkowski | NE |
RB | Chris Johnson | TEN | DE | Mario Williams | HOU | P | Shane Lechler | OAK |
RB | Thomas Jones | NYJ | DT | Albert Haynesworth | TEN | KR | Leodis McKelvin | BUF |
WR | Andre Johnson | HOU | DT | Kris Jenkins | NYJ | PR | Johnnie Lee Higgins | OAK |
WR | Wes Welker | NE | OLB | James Harrison | PIT | ST | Brendon Ayanbadejo | BAL |
TE | Tony Gonzalez | KC | OLB | Joey Porter | MIA | | | |
C | Kevin Mawae | TEN | ILB | Ray Lewis | BAL | | | |
G | Kris Dielman | SD | CB | Nnamdi Asomugha | OAK | | | |
G | Alan Faneca | NYJ | CB | Cortland Finnegan | TEN | | | |
T | Ryan Clady | DEN | S | Troy Polamalu | PIT | | | |
T | Michael Roos | TEN | S | Ed Reed | BAL | | | |
2009 |
| Offense | | | Defense | | | Special Teams | |
QB | Peyton Manning | IND | DE | Dwight Freeney | IND | PK | Nate Kaeding | SD |
RB | Chris Johnson | TEN | DE | Mario Williams | HOU | P | Shane Lechler | OAK |
RB | Maurice Jones-Drew | JAX | DT | Haloti Ngata | BAL | KR | Josh Cribbs | CLE |
WR | Andre Johnson | HOU | DT | Vince Wilfork | NE | PR | Josh Cribbs | CLE |
WR | Wes Welker | NE | OLB | Brian Cushing | HOU | ST | Kassim Osgood | SD |
TE | Dallas Clark | IND | OLB | Elvis Dumervil | DEN | | | |
C | Nick Mangold | NYJ | ILB | Ray Lewis | BAL | | | |
G | Alan Faneca | NYJ | CB | Nnamdi Asomugha | OAK | | | |
G | Logan Mankins | NE | CB | Darrelle Revis | NYJ | | | |
T | Ryan Clady | DEN | S | Jarius Byrd | BUF | | | |
T | Joe Thomas | CLE | S | Brian Dawkins | DEN | | | |
The PFWA’s All-AFC team was presented in conjunction with Pro Football Weekly from 1992-2012.