All-AFC Teams: 2000s | 2010s | 2020s
1992 |
| Offense | | | Defense | | | Special Teams | |
QB | Dan Marino | MIA | DE | Leslie O'Neal | SD | PK | Pete Stoyanovich | MIA |
RB | Barry Foster | PIT | DE | Bruce Smith | BUF | P | Rohn Stark | IND |
RB | Thurman Thomas | BUF | DT | Ray Childress | HOU | KR | Jon Vaughn | NE |
WR | Haywood Jeffires | HOU | DT | Cortez Kennedy | SEA | PR | Clarence Verdin | IND |
WR | Anthony Miller | SD | OLB | Bryan Cox | MIA | ST | Steve Tasker | BUF |
TE | Keith Jackson | MIA | OLB | Derrick Thomas | KC | | | |
C | Bruce Matthews | HOU | ILB | Junior Seau | SD | | | |
G | Mike Munchak | HOU | ILB | Al Smith | HOU | | | |
G | Steve Wisniewski | LARaid | CB | Gill Byrd | SD | | | |
T | Howard Ballard | BUF | CB | Rod Woodson | PIT | | | |
T | Richmond Webb | MIA | S | Steve Atwater | DEN | | | |
| | | S | Henry Jones | BUF | | | |
1993 |
| Offense | | | Defense | | | Special Teams | |
QB | John Elway | DEN | DE | Bruce Smith | BUF | PK | Gary Anderson | PIT |
RB | Marcus Allen | KC | DE | Neil Smith | KC | P | Greg Montgomery | HOU |
RB | Thurman Thomas | BUF | DT | Ray Childress | HOU | KR | O.J. McDuffie | MIA |
WR | Tim Brown | LARaid | DT | Cortez Kennedy | SEA | PR | Eric Metcalf | CLE |
WR | Anthony Miller | SD | OLB | Greg Lloyd | PIT | ST | Steve Tasker | BUF |
TE | Shannon Sharpe | DEN | OLB | Darryl Talley | BUF | | | |
C | Bruce Matthews | HOU | ILB | Vincent Brown | NE | | | |
G | Mike Munchak | HOU | ILB | Junior Seau | SD | | | |
G | Steve Wisniewski | LARaid | CB | Terry McDaniel | LARaid | | | |
T | Howard Ballard | BUF | CB | Rod Woodson | PIT | | | |
T | John Jackson | PIT | S | Marcus Robertson | HOU | | | |
| | | S | Eugene Robinson | SEA | | | |
1994 |
| Offense | | | Defense | | | Special Teams | |
QB | Dan Marino | MIA | DE | Leslie O'Neal | SD | PK | John Carney | SD |
RB | Marshall Faulk | IND | DE | Bruce Smith | BUF | P | Rick Tuten | SEA |
RB | Chris Warren | SEA | DT | Cortez Kennedy | SEA | KR | Andre Coleman | SD |
WR | Tim Brown | LARaid | DT | Chester McGlockton | LARaid | PR | Darrien Gordon | SD |
WR | Andre Reed | BUF | OLB | Kevin Greene | PIT | ST | Steve Tasker | BUF |
TE | Ben Coates | NE | OLB | Greg Lloyd | PIT | | | |
C | Dermontti Dawson | PIT | ILB | Bryan Cox | MIA | | | |
G | Keith Sims | MIA | ILB | Junior Seau | SD | | | |
G | Steve Wisniewski | LARaid | CB | Terry McDaniel | LARaid | | | |
T | Tony Jones | CLE | CB | Rod Woodson | PIT | | | |
T | Richmond Webb | MIA | S | Carnell Lake | PIT | | | |
| | | S | Eric Turner | CLE | | | |
1995 |
| Offense | | | Defense | | | Special Teams | |
QB | Jim Harbaugh | IND | DE | Bruce Smith | BUF | PK | Jason Elam | DEN |
RB | Curtis Martin | NE | DE | Neil Smith | KC | P | Darren Bennett | SD |
RB | Chris Warren | SEA | DT | Chester McGlockton | LARaid | KR | Glyn Milburn | DEN |
WR | Tim Brown | LARaid | DT | Dan Saleaumua | KC | PR | Andre Coleman | SD |
WR | Carl Pickens | CIN | OLB | Greg Lloyd | PIT | ST | Steve Tasker | BUF |
TE | Ben Coates | NE | OLB | Bryce Paup | BUF | | | |
C | Dermontti Dawson | PIT | MLB | Junior Seau | SD | | | |
G | Bruce Matthews | HOU | CB | Dale Carter | KC | | | |
G | Steve Wisniewski | LARaid | CB | Terry McDaniel | LARaid | | | |
T | Bruce Armstrong | NE | S | Blaine Bishop | HOU | | | |
T | Richmond Webb | MIA | S | Carnell Lake | PIT | | | |
1996 |
| Offense | | | Defense | | | Special Teams | |
QB | John Elway | DEN | DE | Bruce Smith | BUF | PK | Cary Blanchard | IND |
RB | Jerome Bettis | PIT | DE | Alfred Williams | DEN | P | Chris Gardocki | IND |
RB | Terrell Davis | DEN | DT | Chester McGlockton | LARaid | KR | Tamarick Vanover | KC |
WR | Tony Martin | SD | DT | Cortez Kennedy | SEA | PR | Darrien Gordon | SD |
WR | Carl Pickens | CIN | OLB | Chad Brown | PIT | ST | John Henry Mills | HOU |
TE | Shannon Sharpe | DEN | OLB | Derrick Thomas | KC | | | |
C | Dermontti Dawson | PIT | MLB | Levon Kirkland | PIT | | | |
G | Will Shields | KC | CB | Ashley Ambrose | CIN | | | |
G | Steve Wisniewski | LARaid | CB | Dale Carter | KC | | | |
T | Bruce Armstrong | NE | S | Steve Atwater | DEN | | | |
T | Gary ZImmerman | DEN | S | Carnell Lake | PIT | | | |
1997 |
| Offense | | | Defense | | | Special Teams | |
QB | John Elway | DEN | DE | Michael Sinclair | SEA | PK | Pete Stoyanovich | KC |
RB | Jerome Bettis | PIT | DE | Bruce Smith | BUF | P | Bryan Barker | JAX |
RB | Terrell Davis | DEN | DT | Joel Steed | PIT | KR | Tamarick Vanover | KC |
WR | Tim Brown | OAK | DT | Ted Washington | BUF | PR | Darrien Gordon | DEN |
WR | Yancey Thigpen | PIT | OLB | John Mobley | DEN | ST | Larry Whigham | NE |
TE | Shannon Sharpe | DEN | OLB | Chris Slade | NE | | | |
C | Dermontti Dawson | PIT | MLB | Levon Kirkland | PIT | | | |
G | Bruce Matthews | TEN | CB | Aaron Glenn | NYJ | | | |
G | Dave Scott | KC | CB | Dale Carter
James Hasty | KC
KC | | | |
T | Tony Boselli | JAX | S | Carnell Lake | PIT | | | |
T | Jonathan Ogden | BAL | S | Darryl Williams | SEA | | | |
1998 |
| Offense | | | Defense | | | Special Teams | |
QB | Vinny Testaverde | NYJ | DE | Michael McCrary | BAL | PK | Jason Elam | DEN |
RB | Terrell Davis | DEN | DE | Michael Sinclair | SEA | P | Craig Hentrich | TEN |
RB | Marshall Faulk | IND | DT | Darrell Russell | OAK | KR | Vaughn Hebron | DEN |
WR | Keyshawn Johnson | NYJ | DT | Ted Washington | BUF | PR | Jermaine Lewis | BAL |
WR | Eric Moulds | BUF | OLB | Chad Brown | SEA | ST | Bennie Thompson | BAL |
TE | Shannon Sharpe | DEN | OLB | Mo Lewis | NYJ | | | |
C | Dermontti Dawson | PIT | MLB | Junior Seau | SD | | | |
G | Ruben Brown | BUF | CB | Aaron Glenn | NYJ | | | |
G | Bruce Matthews | TEN | CB | Ty Law | NE | | | |
T | Tony Boselli | JAX | S | Rodney Harrison | SD | | | |
T | Jonathan Ogden | BAL | S | Lawyer Milloy | NE | | | |
1999 |
| Offense | | | Defense | | | Special Teams | |
QB | Peyton Manning | IND | DE | Tony Brackens | JAX | PK | Olindo Mare | MIA |
RB | Eddie George | TEN | DE | Jevon Kearse | TEN | P | Tom Tupa | NYJ |
RB | Edgerrin James | IND | DT | Trevor Pryce | DEN | KR | Tremain Mack | CIN |
WR | Marvin Harrison | IND | DT | Darrell Russell | OAK | PR | Charlie Rogers | SEA |
WR | Jimmy Smith | JAX | OLB | Peter Boulware | BAL | ST | Detron Smith | DEN |
TE | Tony Gonzalez | KC | OLB | Kevin Hardy | JAX | | | |
C | Kevin Mawae | NYJ | MLB | Ray Lewis | BAL | | | |
G | Ruben Brown | BUF | CB | Sam Madison | MIA | | | |
G | Bruce Matthews | TEN | CB | Charles Woodson | OAK | | | |
T | Tony Boselli | JAX | S | Carnell Lake | JAX | | | |
T | Jonathan Ogden | BAL | S | Lawyer Milloy | NE | | | |
The PFWA’s All-NFL teams were presented in conjunction with Pro Football Weekly from 1992-2012.
Many thanks to John Turney of the Professional Football Researchers Association for his assistance in completing the PFWA’s award history.