All-Rookie Teams: 1970s | 1980s | 2000s | 2010s | 2020s
1990 |
| Offense | | | Defense | | | Special Teams | |
QB | Jeff George | IND | DE | Ray Agnew | NE | PK | Steve Christie | TB |
RB | Johnny Johnson | PHX | DE | Renaldo Turnbull | SD | | | |
RB | Emmitt Smith | DAL | DT | Jimmie Jones | DAL | | | |
WR | Fred Barnett | PHI | DT | Cortez Kennedy | SEA | | | |
WR | Rob Moore
Ricky Proehl | NYJ
PHX | OLB | James Francis | CIN | | | |
TE | Eric Green | PIT | OLB | Aaron Wallace | LARaid | | | |
C | Tim Grunhard | KC | ILB | Percy Snow | KC | | | |
G | Keith Sims | MIA | CB | Ben Smith | PHI | | | |
G | Dave Szott | KC | CB | James Williams | BUF | | | |
T | Leo Goeas | SD | S | Robert Blackmon | SEA | | | |
T | Richmond Webb | MIA | S | Mark Carrier | CHI | | | |
1991 |
| Offense | | | Defense | | | Special Teams | |
QB | no selection | | DE | Phil Hansen | BUF | PK | John Kasay | PHI |
RB | Ricky Ervins | WAS | DE | Kenny Walker | DEN | | | |
RB | Leonard Russell | NE | DT | Moe Gardner | ATL | | | |
WR | Lawrence Dawsey | TB | DT | Russell Maryland | DAL | | | |
WR | Mike Pritchard | ATL | OLB | Mike Croel | DEN | | | |
TE | Adrian Cooper | PIT | OLB | Mo Lewis | NYJ | | | |
C | John Flannery | HOU | ILB | Darrick Brownlow | DAL | | | |
G | Ed King | CLE | ILB | Keith Traylor | DEN | | | |
G | Eric Moten | SD | CB | Larry Brown | DAL | | | |
T | Antone Davis | PHI | CB | Aeneas Williams | PHX | | | |
T | Pat Harlow | NE | S | Stanley Richard | SD | | | |
| | | S | Eric Turner | CLE | | | |
1992 |
| Offense | | | Defense | | | Special Teams | |
QB | David Klingler | CIN | DE | Santana Dotson | TB | PK | Jason Hanson | DET |
RB | Vaughn Dunbar | NO | DE | Chris Mims | SD | P | Klaus Wilmsmeyer | SF |
RB | Amp Lee | SF | DT | Steve Emtman | ATL | KR | Desmond Howard | WAS |
WR | Carl Pickens | CIN | DT | Sean Gilbert | LARams | PR | Dale Carter | KC |
WR | Arthur Marshall | DEN | OLB | Quentin Coryatt | IND | ST | Darren Woodson | DAL |
TE | Johnny Mitchell | NYJ | OLB | Marco Coleman | MIA | | | |
C | Matt Elliott | WAS | ILB | Robert Jones | DAL | | | |
G | no selection | | ILB | Ricardo McDonald | CIN | | | |
G | no selection | | CB | Dale Carter | KC | | | |
T | Troy Auzenne | CHI | CB | Troy Vincent | MIA | | | |
T | Eugene Chung | NE | S | Dana Hall | SF | | | |
| | | S | Darren Perry | PIT | | | |
1993 |
| Offense | | | Defense | | | Special Teams | |
QB | Rick Mirer | SEA | DE | John Copeland | CIN | PK | Jason Elam | DEN |
RB | Jerome Bettis | LARams | DE | Eric Curry | TB | P | John Jett | DAL |
RB | Reggie Brooks | WAS | DT | Leonard Renfro | PHI | KR | Tyrone Hughes | NO |
WR | Vincent Brisby | NE | DT | Dana Stubblefield | SF | PR | Tyrone Hughes | NO |
WR | James Jett | LARaid | OLB | Darrin Smith | DAL | ST | Jessie Armstead | NYG |
TE | Tony McGee | CIN | OLB | Wayne Simmons | GB | | | |
C | Steve Everitt | CLE | ILB/MLB | Chad Brown | PIT | | | |
G | Lincoln Kennedy | ATL | ILB/MLB | Steve Tovar | CIN | | | |
G | Will Shields | KC | CB | Tom Carter | WAS | | | |
T | Brad Hopkins | HOU | CB | Darrien Gordon | SD | | | |
T | Willie Roaf | NO | S | Roger Harper | ATL | | | |
| | | S | George Teague | GB | | | |
1994 |
| Offense | | | Defense | | | Special Teams | |
QB | Heath Shuler | WAS | DE | Sam Adams | SEA | PK | Chris Boniol | DAL |
RB | Marshall Faulk | IND | DE | Joe Johnson | NO | P | Pat O'Neill | NE |
RB | Errict Rhett | TB | DT | Tim Bowens | MIA | KR | Andre Coleman | SD |
WR | Derrick Alexander | CLE | DT | Bryant Young | SF | PR | Jeff Burris | BUF |
WR | Darnay Scott | CIN | LB | Aubrey Beavers | MIA | ST | Sam Rogers | BUF |
TE | Andrew Jordan | MIN | LB | Rob Fredrickson | LARaid | | | |
C | Kevin Mawae | SEA | LB | Willie McGinest | NE | | | |
G | Joe Panos | PHI | LB | Lee Woodall | SF | | | |
G | Anthony Redmon | ARI | CB | Antonio Langham | CLE | | | |
T | Larry Allen | DAL | CB | Dewayne Washington | MIN | | | |
T | Todd Steussie | MIN | S | Keith Lyle | LARams | | | |
| | | S | Darryl Morrison | WAS | | | |
1995 |
| Offense | | | Defense | | | Special Teams | |
QB | Kerry Collins | CAR | DE | Hugh Douglas | NYJ | PK | Cole Ford | OAK |
RB | Terrell Davis | DEN | DE | Mike Mamula | PHI | P | Tom Hutton | PHI |
RB | Curtis Martin | NE | DT | Warren Sapp | TB | KR | Tamarick Vanover | KC |
WR | Joey Galloway | SEA | DT | Gary Walker | HOU | PR | Tamarick Vanover | KC |
WR | Chris Sanders | HOU | LB | Derrick Brooks | TB | ST | Chad Cascadden | NYJ |
TE | Ken Dilger | IND | LB | Mark Fields | NO | | | |
C | Dave Wohlbaugh | NE | LB | Ted Johnson | NE | | | |
G | Ruben Brown | BUF | CB | Tyrone Poole | CAR | | | |
G | Brenden Stai | PIT | CB | Bobby Taylor | PHI | | | |
T | Tony Boselli | JAX | S | Devin Bush | ATL | | | |
T | Blake Brockermeyer | CAR | S | Orlando Thomas | MIN | | | |
1996 |
| Offense | | | Defense | | | Special Teams | |
QB | Tony Banks | STL | DE | Tony Brackens | JAX | PK | Adam Vinatieri | NE |
RB | Karim Abdul-Jabbar | MIA | DE | Simeon Rice | ARI | P | no selection | |
RB | Eddie George | HOU | DT | Daryl Gardener | MIA | KR | Eric Moulds | BUF |
WR | Terry Glenn | NE | DT | Devin Wyman | NE | PR | Eddie Kennison | STL |
WR | Eddie Kennison | STL | LB | Kevin Hardy | JAX | ST | Larry Izzo | MIA |
TE | Jason Dunn | PHI | LB | John Mobley | DEN | | | |
C | Aaron Graham | ARI | LB | Zach Thomas | MIA | | | |
G | Jeff Hartings | DET | CB | Donnie Abraham | TB | | | |
G | Jonathan Ogden | BAL | CB | Walt Harris | CHI | | | |
T | Willie Anderson | CIN | S | Brian Dawkins | PHI | | | |
T | John Michels | GB | S | Lawyer Milloy | NE | | | |
1997 |
| Offense | | | Defense | | | Special Teams | |
QB | Jake Plummer | ARI | DE | Darrell Russell | OAK | PK | John Hall | NYJ |
RB | Corey Dillon | CIN | DE | Jason Taylor | MIA | P | Ken Walter | CAR |
RB | Warrick Dunn | TB | DT | Antonio Anderson | DAL | KR | Byron Hanspard | ATL |
WR | Reidel Anthony | TB | DT | Renaldo Wynn | JAX | PR | Leon Johnson | NYJ |
WR | Rae Carruth | CAR | OLB | Peter Boulware | BAL | ST | no selection | |
TE | Tony Gonzalez | KC | OLB | Dexter Coakley | DAL | | | |
C | Calvin Collins | ATL | ILB | Matt Russell | DET | | | |
G | Tarik Glenn | IND | CB | Shawn Springs | SEA | | | |
G | Frank Middleton | TB | CB | Bryant Westbrook | DET | | | |
T | Walter Jones | SEA | S | Sam Garnes | NYG | | | |
T | Ross Verba | GB | S | Sammy Knight | NO | | | |
1998 |
| Offense | | | Defense | | | Special Teams | |
QB | Peyton Manning | IND | DE | Vonnie Holliday | GB | PK | Mike Vanderjagt | IND |
RB | Robert Edwards | NE | DE | Andre Wadsworth | ARI | P | Brad Costello | CIN |
RB | Fred Taylor | JAX | DT | Larry Chester | IND | KR | Terry Fair | DET |
WR | Randy Moss | MIN | DT | Brandon Whiting | PHI | PR | Jacquez Green | TB |
WR | Jerome Pathon | IND | LB | Sam Cowart | BUF | ST | Tim Dwight | ATL |
TE | Cam Cleeland | NO | LB | Anthony Simmons | SEA | | | |
C | Kevin Long | TEN | LB | Takeo Spikes | CIN | | | |
G | Steve McKinney | IND | CB | Terry Fair | DET | | | |
G | Kyle Turley | NO | CB | Charles Woodson | OAK | | | |
T | Jason Fabini | NYJ | S | Donovin Darius | JAX | | | |
T | Ephraim Salaam | ATL | S | Tony Parrish | CHI | | | |
1999 |
| Offense | | | Defense | | | Special Teams | |
QB | Tim Couch | CLE | DE | Russell Davis | CHI | PK | Martin Gramatica | TB |
RB | Olandis Gary | DEN | DE | Ebenezer Ekuban | DAL | P | Hunter Smith | IND |
RB | Edgerrin James | IND | DE | Jevon Kearse | TEN | KR | Terrence Wilkins | IND |
WR | Torry Holt | STL | DT | Jason Wiltz | NYJ | PR | Charlie Rogers | SEA |
WR | Kevin Johnson | CLE | LB | Chris Claiborne | DET | ST | John McLaughlin | TB |
TE | Jed Weaver | PHI | LB | Andy Katzenmoyer | NE | | | |
C | Damien Woody | NE | LB | Mike Peterson | IND | | | |
G | Doug Brzezinski | PHI | CB | Champ Bailey | WAS | | | |
G | Randy Thomas | NYJ | CB | Fernando Bryant | JAX | | | |
T | Jon Jansen | WAS | S | Cory Hall | CIN | | | |
T | Chris Terry | CAR | S | Jason Perry | SD | | | |
The PFWA’s All-NFL teams were presented in conjunction with Pro Football Weekly from 1992-2012.
Many thanks to John Turney of the Professional Football Researchers Association for his assistance in completing the PFWA’s award history.