All-Rookie Teams: 1970s | 1980s | 1990s | 2000s | 2010s
| 2020 |
| Offense | | | Defense | | | Special Teams | |
| QB | Justin Herbert | LAC | DL | Derrick Brown | CAR | PK | Rodrigo Blankenship | IND |
| RB | James Robinson | JAX | DL | Raekwon Davis | MIA | P | Tommy Townsend | KC |
| RB | Jonathan Taylor | IND | DL | Javon Kinlaw | SF | KR | Isaiah Rodgers | IND |
| WR | Chase Claypool | PIT | DL | Chase Young | WAS | PR | James Proche II | BAL |
| WR | Justin Jefferson | MIN | LB | Kenneth Murray Jr. | LAC | ST | Jordan Glasgow | IND |
| TE | Harrison Bryant | CLE | LB | Patrick Queen | BAL | | | |
| C | Lloyd Cushenberry III | DEN | LB | Isaiah Simmons | ARI | | | |
| G | Damien Lewis | SEA | CB | Cameron Dantzler | MIN | | | |
| G | Mike Onwenu | NE | CB | L’Jarius Sneed | KC | | | |
| T | Jedrick Wills Jr. | CLE | S | Jeremy Chinn | CAR | | | |
| T | Tristan Wirfs | TB | S | Antoine Winfield Jr. | TB | | | |
| 2021 |
| Offense | | | Defense | | | Special Teams | |
| QB | Mac Jones | NE | DL | Christian Barmore | NE | PK | Evan McPherson | CIN |
| RB | Najee Harris | PIT | DL | Odafe Oweh | BAL | P | Pressley Harvin III | PIT |
| RB | Javonte Williams | DEN | DL | Kwity Paye | IND | KR | Kene Nwangwu | MIN |
| WR | Ja’Marr Chase | CIN | DL | Jaelan Phillips | MIA | PR | Demetric Felton | CLE |
| WR | Jaylen Waddle | MIA | LB | Nick Bolton | KC | ST | Nick Niemann | LAC |
| TE | Kyle Pitts | ATL | LB | Jeremiah Owusu-Koramoah | CLE | | | |
| C | Creed Humphrey | KC | LB | Micah Parsons | DAL | | | |
| G | Trey Smith | KC | CB | Greg Newsome II | CLE | | | |
| G | Alijah Vera-Tucker | NYJ | CB | Patrick Surtain II | DEN | | | |
| T | Rashawn Slater | LAC | S | Jevon Holland | MIA | | | |
| T | Penei Sewell | DET | S | Tre’Von Moehrig | LV | | | |
| 2022 |
| Offense | | | Defense | | | Special Teams | |
| QB | Brock Purdy | SF | DL | Jordan Davis | PHI | PK | Cameron Dicker | LAC |
| RB | Tyler Allgeier | ATL | DL | Aidan Hutchinson | DET | P | Ryan Stonehouse | TEN |
| RB | Kenneth Walker III | SEA | DL | George Karlaftis | KC | KR | Dallis Flowers | IND |
| WR | Chris Olave | NO | DL | Kayvon Thibodeaux | NYG | PR | Marcus Jones | NE |
| WR | Garrett Wilson | NYJ | LB | Devin Lloyd | JAX | ST | Brenden Schooler | NE |
| TE | Chigoziem Okonkwo | TEN | LB | Malcolm Rodriguez | DET | | | |
| C | Tyler Linderbaum | BAL | LB | Quay Walker | GB | | | |
| G | Zion Johnson | LAC | CB | Ahmad “Sauce” Gardner | NYJ | | | |
| G | Dylan Parham | LV | CB | Tariq Woolen | SEA | | | |
| T | Braxton Jones | CHI | S | Kyle Hamilton | BAL | | | |
| T | Tyler Smith | DAL | S | Jalen Pitre | HOU | | | |
| 2023 |
| Offense | | | Defense | | | Special Teams | |
| QB | C.J. Stroud | HOU | DL | Will Anderson Jr. | HOU | PK | Jake Moody | SF |
| RB | Jahmyr Gibbs | DET | DL | Jalen Carter | PHI | P | Bryce Baringer | NE |
| RB | Bijan Robinson | ATL | DL | Tuli Tuipulotu | LAC | KR | Marvin Mims Jr. | DEN |
| WR | Jordan Addison | MIN | DL | Kobie Turner | LAR | PR | Derius Davis | LAC |
| WR | Puka Nacua | LAR | LB | Jack Campbell | DET | ST | Jerrick Reed II | SEA |
| TE | Sam LaPorta | DET | LB | Ivan Pace Jr. | MIN | | | |
| C | Joe Tippmann | NYJ | LB | Byron Young | LAR | | | |
| G | Steve Avila | LAR | CB | Joey Porter Jr. | PIT | | | |
| G | O’Cyrus Torrence | BUF | CB | Devon Witherspoon | SEA | | | |
| T | Dawand Jones | CLE | S | Jordan Battle | CIN | | | |
| T | Darnell Wright | CHI | S | Ji’Ayir Brown | SF | | | |
